I’ve been asked a few times for reasons why I’m a vegetarian. So I thought, considering that I haven’t blogged in a while I’d write it down.
As you may know I’m Asian and a Muslim – two traits that make it almost impossible to become a vegetarian, stick with it and not be questioned about it. Yet I have defied this and have adopted a largely vegetarian diet. People have often said that it’s actually against my religion but I find that my faith positively encourages eating a diet of little meat.
Whilst researching for this (yes, I am that much of a nerd), even I was surprised at the ‘vegetarian movement’ amongst Muslims today. Their reasons for looking at what they eat more carefully are pretty much similar to my own. Although their research was a bit more extensive than mine before they started becoming vegetarian.
For me, it all started when I moved out to go to uni in 2006. For some odd reason from that day, until almost a year later, the smell of meat (cooked and raw) would make me feel really ill. Considering it was Ramadhan and I kinda needed to eat I became a vegetarian. It was actually was a hard decision to make – especially since that meant I wouldn’t get food from the prayer hall and had to break my fast on my own in my halls.
Whilst in this mode I decided to do more research into what my faith said about the subject. Firstly I considered the life of the Prophet Mohammed (the sunnah). A lot of Muslims take the way that the Prophet lived to be the model way to live their lives. Thinking about the region and society in which the Prophet lived in then I came to realise that it seemed unlikely that he would have eaten that much meat – and that is something that people who wrote about his life also agreed on. He never refused it when offered but generally the consensus is that he ate is about once a month. The Prophet led a very simple life and meat was quite rare in those times. This is generally because of the emphasis that the society at that time put on livestock as a form of wealth. That is why cattle were used as dowry and a status symbol. Don’t get me wrong – trade was the main way of gaining wealth in those times but, much like some cultures today, cattle were seen as an expression of it.
Looking at that meant that I also ended up looking at things that the Prophets and scholars have said about eating meat. Chief among these sayings that I found was a saying by Imam Ali was ‘don’t make your stomach the graveyard of animals’. I noticed that at home we ate meat every day and probably ate vegetarian food once a month. To be honest this made me feel incredibly guilty, at one point I think I even said that I need to make up for all the years of travesty against animals.
However, there was also a saying by the Prophet that said that you should eat meat at least every 40 days. Apparently this is the saying that many people use to argue that Muslims cannot be vegetarians. To be honest, it’s the reason why I eat meat sometimes, though I don’t like to do so. However, I don’t think it justifies non-vegetarianism. As with most ‘food laws’ it’s important not to forget the context in which these things were said.
For example:
The saying – There’s a recommendation to eat salt when breaking your fast. The context – the Prophet lived in a very hot climate and when it’s hot you sweat and lose the salt that your body needs, so it was necessary to replenish the stores. The fact that Britain has a mild climate and that our diet has considerably more salt in it then we actually need means that we should not have to do this.
Meat is similar – people in hotter climates need the nutrients and people who have a more active lifestyle need the protein that meat provides.
It’s important to note that I do not believe meat is forbidden (haram). In fact I’m fine with eating it but I believe that anything in excess is bad. It’s a choice that I’m glad I made.
Peace